MicroBlogging with Intense Debate
Related Readings |
MicroBlogging is being spoken of all over the blogosphere. Is it good? Will I produce traffic? Can I make money off it?
The answer is NO, in my opinion. The reason for this is microblogging is small sentences or groups of words that create a small issue. Comments for example are forms of micro blogging.
What is Micro Bloggin exactly?
It is a form of blogging that lets you write brief text updates about your life or situation while on the go and send them to friends and interested observers via text messaging, instant messaging, email or the web. The most popular service is called Twitter.
After the launch of Twitter a lot of small service wanted to take in this popularity and produce other microblogging sites. Once that I joined is ofcourse Twitter and the other is Pownce.
These sites just lets you post small information on what is happening currently or what is on your mind at the moment and just upload it to a website.
Since I stated comments are a form of microblogging. There is a website that helps with this called IntenseDebate. TechCrunch says Intense Debate is:
Intense Debate is a souped-up blog commenting system that adds a lot of features for publishers and commenters alike. Installing the plug-in on your blog (WordPress, Blogger, and TypePad) adds threading, comment analytics, bulk comment moderation across all your blogs, user reputation, and comment aggregation. You can test out the system on the TechStars blog, but you’ll have to apply to the private beta if you want to install it on your own.
Since it will replace your WordPress comment system you will not be using your databse to store these comments you will be using Intense Debate’s servers for the storage of comments. Will this be useful for bloggers?
I do see some positive and that is exposure of other blogs. Once you sign up you are given a profile, which will track all your comments you left on blogs that HAVE the intense debate plugin installed. It tracks how many comments you have posted and even show what blogs.
It shows threaded comments by the commenter who has left any comments on any blog (<- did that make sense?), you can even subscribe to their RSS. Here is a view of a user public profile. To the left you can see all the blogs the user has commented on and to what blog too!
This is the only reason I can see that it can be helpful to a blogger.
The negatives, I think is that commenting should be what the reader is thinking about your post. Though Intense Debate is about commenting on real post, they are being scored. Why would you want to score your comment? The more you comment the higher rep you get within their community, but for what? During the tour this is what is said:
Rate the comments you read and determine which comments rise to the top and which fall to the bottom.
Gain authority through a reputation system based on the number of comments you’ve made and the quality of those comments as determined by the other users.
I think this is good for networking to an extent but gaining authority within the community because you post more comments than the commenter next to you? I don’t know.
For me I will not be joining because I think comments should be comments and not be provided points. Though this is a good way to use Web 2.0, I think commenting on blogs should be left to the reader and that alone. I might be wrong on this since I have decided not to join, but let us see what other bloggers say about this.
Today is the final release of intense debate since it has finished beta testing. You can see the plugin in action within their blog post.

What do you think of this new system? Will this change how commenting is done? Will comments be considered blogging?




Hmm, how long before they add the option of splitting up revenue among frequent commentators? If you post a well-thought-out, particularly insightful comment, can’t you make the argument that you should receive some ad profits from the page?
> Sam
but if that is so that would ruin the concept of blogging and communication, it is similar to buyblogcomments if you are stating that because people will just comment just because they are going to get paid – will they read the post, will they contribute something useful? etc pay to comment does not sound to good to my ears
Guys, Josh from Intense Debate here. I would like to take up some of the points you mention in the article.
First, we provide a hosted solution. the blog’s comments will go on our servers, that is true. This is no different than folks using blogger to blog and gmail for their email. We don’t hide this. For those hung up on this issue, we provide an importer/exporter so that they can have all the data from their comments at any time. We do feel it is useful to the publisher because 1)with javascript, the publisher isnt forced to download new versions as they come out. we fix bugs immediately. also, we are able to offer some really great features because of this.
Points are nothing new when it comes to comments. Digg has used them for quite a while. We use the points to help in the calculation of a reputation and to help with fighting spam or pointless posts. We can use it for filtering purposes that havent been released.
Our whole goal is to make the commenting experience better so that communication is spurred and blogs truly become conversation tools.
To address your first two points, I am not sure people who use services like twitter and others are out to make money with their little blurbs. In my opinion they do it to market themselves or their services. As far as publishers who use our service, we will introduce revenue generating solutions for them later.
Ian, our data suggests that our service does bring traffic to blogs and people generally stay on the blogs longer. So, really good things. If you have any questions, comments, or concerns you can email me directly at josh at intensedebate dot com
[...] have been talking about twitter several times on my blog. Twitter has been very beneficial to me in several ways. The fact that I am able to [...]
i think, it quite good, although some matters, it doesn’t make money
Got something to say? Click Here to Say something then!
Leave your response!
Subscribe
Recent Comments
Blog Poll
Connect With Me
Random Photos
View more photos >
Latest Video
Recent Posts
Most Commented
Most Popular