Quantcast

Surgically Determining Facebook via Cost Per Sale

The past couple days even weeks I have been playing around with CPS via Facebook. I figured that I should start cashing in on the Halloween season and attempt to make some quick easy money via Facebook. I figured facebook would be easier, well I was wrong. I have  nice case study which you can look over and let me know your ideas.

Obviously the niche I chose was Halloween costumes. This case study will be about the Dexter costume as I am promoting other types of costumes within and out of Facebook. Also, I opened a new facebook account for promoting just Halloween costumes.

I figured costumes, the target is everyone. I was wrong and def got me spending about 100$ every 5-7 minutes. SO I stopped those campaigns and re-thought my strategy because I can’t type in the keywords “costumes” via facebook because it didn’t even come up.

Here is a quick wrap up of my spending, taken on 10/12/09:

fbmoneysm

So I had to think of another way to target the demographics.

It took me a good day to figure this out.

This is how I started targeting. Since Facebook keywords are specific by interests, likes, music, shows, etc. I decided to target users by TV shows. For example, one of the costumes I was promoting via Facebook was Dexter costumes, so I targeted Dexter, the network it was on,and even some characters from the show. I got a good amount of users which I was kinda surprised.

The next thing I did was split test among age groups. This made it easy for me to see what age group produced the most clicks. Once I saw a good valid amount of clicks, I broke it down even more into their own ad group by age. So this way I can tell and see who are buying and where the majority of the clicks are coming from.

dexterfbHere is the Dexter ad I was running. I kept it very simple and straight to the point, since that is what Facebook likes. Also it was very easy to get the ads approved because I was direct linking to the actual costume. So it was instantly approved.

I also had the word Halloween and Costume in the copy, so it emphasis that it is a costume and not a special on the TV show, since I was targeting by the TV show and the network. I wanted to make sure that the person clicking on the ad was looking at  costume.

I thought my CTR was good that I would see some conversions, don’t think it works like that with CPS. So I was thinking what was going on between the click and the merchants website. With the clicks that is happening I basically stared at the set landing page for the costume and tried to figure out what would be wrong.

But as an affiliate there are limits on what we can do on the merchants LP, especially I think it is a e commerce style website.

Anyways here are my general stats before I started breaking them up even more. As you can see my CTR is fairly high for facebook .1 – .5. I know personally that those CTRs would be good for CPA offers.

dexterspendsm

My Spending

Now the spending per click didn’t pay off for the payout I was receiving. Since this was a $50+ costume I had to sell 1 costume every 10 clicks to come out fairly even. If my spending per click was .50 I had to sell a costume every 10 clicks, which didn’t work in my favor.

I started off bidding high because I wanted to get the most clicks to see how costumes would work on Facebook, I wanted to make sure my ad was being shown on Facebook everywhere. This way I have data I can look at right away, I hate waiting for data. So I started my MAX CPC at .85 making sure I will be on top before anyone else targeting the interests I was targeting.

You can also see I had the impressions going in my favor. Also if you are looking at the age groups the younger crowd are the ones who were most active and the ones who click through to the ad, all males BTW.

Now I think I should have done a CPM model just because I was getting a high CTR. The reason why I didnt do it was I wasn’t getting enough conversions or rarely any. But honestly now that I think about it while writing this post I should have done the CPM model as it would have been cheaper than CPC.

Case Study Wrap Up

  1. Spent a Total of $205.25 on Dexter Campaign
  2. Earned a Total of $16 on Dexter Campaign

* payout was 10% per sale

The basis of this even though it didn’t convert very well I learned a lot by just split testing and spending money in a field I was not familiar with CPS on Facebook isn’t my forte but I wouldn’t mind doing it again since now I have a better understanding with CPS on Facebook. I know some people that just do CPS via Facebook and make a living.

Start small and then scale, but also spend a good amount where you have decent data to look at. I personally didn’t spend that much but I have the data that helped me make the decisions I made to try to make this work in my favor.

Let me know what else you think I should have done, what other strategies I might have missed. What are your thoughts on this case study? Are you promoting Halloween costumes?

But all in all test and make the mistakes to learn!

BTW ReTweet this ish!

  • http://profitapolis.com ImagesAndWords

    Hey man,
    Yeah CPS is a different ballgame, and the weakest link so to say can often be the product’s landing page. With CPA offers you often have several similar offers to split test between, and even if you don’t – they’re already optimized pretty well by the merchant for maximum conversion.

    Not so with CPS / products. Some merchants are better than others at keeping their pages appealing and converting. But when it comes to CPS you also gotta keep in mind things like people’s trust factor with the site (does it seem “credit card safe”? does it seem like a reputable store?, etc.). People ask themselves this as soon as they get to the merchant’s site.

    Even if they want that product real bad (and the price is good), something or other may turn them off. But of course – there IS money to be made with CPS. With the costume test, perhaps you could see if other merchants (on CJ or ShareaSale) could provide the same product so you could split-test?

    And… try to add some words in your adcopy to reassure the clicker that the site he/she is about to go to is a great place to shop. Tell them upfront about shipping deals, how many people have been satisfied with this buy, etc.

    Make it hard for them NOT to buy that costume! ;)

  • http://www.adhustler.com Ad Hustler

    PRICE! Put the price in the ad. It will hurt your CTR, but it will qualify the clicks making it much more likely they will actually convert once they click.

  • http://wellontop.com/ Sean Weigold Ferguson

    Facebook Ads are a powerful but challenging platform. To teach you all of the nuances could fill a book, but I’ll leave you with a couple of tips.

    1. Always use CPM. CPM on Facebook Ads is freaking amazing if you know what you’re doing.

    2. Research, research, research. Success with Facebook Ads requires a deep, thorough understanding of your ideal customer.

    3. Keep it on Facebook. Create a Facebook Page and iframe your LP. Your conversion rate doubles.

  • http://bryn.me Bryn Youngblut

    Slutty Halloween costumes = ftw

    You know how well hot girls images work on fb…works amazing for guys AND girls.

  • http://www.ianfernando.com Ian

    @bryn
    I am actually doing some skanky costumes – lots of clicks and teh scary part its from women who are 40+

    @hustler
    ahh good idea – probably best to put it in the title

    @sean
    yea I should have def probably went with CPM instead. that iframe thing hmm might have to try that out

    @imageandwords
    yea I def think the costume page needed work. I gave them my two cents on it

  • Pingback: Why Facebook is Best for Branding

  • http://twitter.com/yeabuddy Casey

    DEFINITELY DEFINITELY get these ads switched over to CPM. With a CTR of .5 you can get SUPER cheap clicks.

  • http://twitter.com/lenstrom Kiley

    Yeah, dude, oldest trick in the book; numbers in the ad copy.

  • Pingback: Surgically Determining Facebook via Cost Per Sale | Red Button Reviews

  • http://www.businessmobilephone.net/business-mobiles/ business mobiles

    I am learning all these tricks I will use these when I am going to make money with blogging.

  • http://8disk.net game-girl

    The oldest tricks may look the new ones if you look at them from the other side.

  • xentech

    Man! If you did CPM bidding on that dexter campaign you would be paying under 10 cents per click, easy.